•
|
|
|
|
Rank of rating systems.
Possible You do not know that e-rating help Bill Gates to be 6-th in Forbes Rank List. I think that he do not know about it too. So let him know :))
Kenneth Massey has made a remarkable thing - has collected about hundred ranking systems of College Football teams. And having assumed, that as behind everyone ranking authors stand and all of them are equal and are the experts as though armed with mathematics. And time so that is naturally simple to calculate certain average ranking, for example, by summing ranks of teams. As has truly noticed by Kenneth Massey models of an estimation of validity of ranks much. Probably as much how many models of ranks. More or less the general structure probably is fair. ESTIMATION of the MISTAKE = Here: IMPORTANCE of MISTAKE = ESTIMATION of
WINNER'S RANK + SIZE of MISTAKE = ESTIMATION of DEFEATED RANK - ESTIMATION of WINNER'S RANK It results in beautiful expression: ESTIMATION of MISTAKE = ESTIMATION of RANK DEFEATED ^ 2 - ESTIMATION of WINNER'S RANK ^ 2 For the elementary estimation of the RANK of participants was used RANK ESTIMATION = N - RANK However it is not only one of possible elementary arithmetic expressions.
Err gives us teams points of view. (The less number of errors - the better) WE presents fans points of view. (Errors in top of ranking list has lager weight) Saturday, December 5, 2004 (105 Rankings)Teams PW Fans PW Trade PW TOTALS Rnk Links ABR Err Rnk WE Rnk Adv Rnk SumRnk 2 The Sports Report TSR 98 17 193 4 88 1 22 3 Massey BCS MB 98 17 198 5 94 2 24 5 Wilson WIL 98 17 203 8 95 3 28 22 Wobus WOB 101 31 227 35 98 4 70 3 Rothman RTH 98 17 191 2 99 5 24 1 CPA Retro CPR 81 4 206 11 100 6 21 8 Ashburn ASH 101 31 199 6 102 7 44 12 Sagarin-Elo SE 101 31 209 14 104 8 53 14 Sagarin SAG 101 31 215 21 105 9 61 7 Slots SLT 74 2 218 26 105 10 38 51 Daniel DAN 111 79 240 55 108 11 145 11 BC Moore BCM 98 17 216 23 108 12 52 14 Matthews MAT 102 38 205 10 108 13 61 24 Bihl BIH 103 43 213 18 108 14 75 19 CollemanMV CMV 54 1 237 50 109 15 66 25 Boyer-DeSimone BD 104 50 208 13 109 16 79 17 Random Monkeys RM 98 17 221 30 110 17 64 9 Dolphin DOL 89 5 215 22 112 18 45 10 E-Rating (BSJ) ER(BCS) 97 10 213 17 113 19 46 41 Claassen CLA 106 62 237 49 113 20 131 29 Mease MEA 102 38 230 41 114 21 100 6 Self SEL 96 8 193 3 115 22 33 45 Wolfe WOL 104 50 243 60 116 23 133 17 Rudacille RUD 101 31 204 9 117 24 64 38 Bobcat D1A 105 58 232 42 117 25 125 21 Massey MAS 99 24 214 19 117 26 69 32 Minton MTN 107 65 215 20 117 27 112 14 CPA CPA 98 17 212 16 118 28 61 32 Massey COMP Consens 104 50 223 33 118 29 112 19 Greenfield GRN 99 24 207 12 118 30 66 55 Laz Index LAZ 107 65 243 59 118 31 155 41 Junky's JNK 99 24 251 75 118 32 131 31 Colley COL 96 8 246 67 119 33 108 23 Anderson AND 97 10 218 27 119 34 71 58 Howell HOW 104 50 256 79 119 35 164 35 Sauceda SAU 107 65 211 15 120 36 116 46 Reese RSE 103 43 239 54 120 37 134 41 Overtake & Feedback OAF 120 92 170 1 121 38 131 40 McMurry MMY 107 65 217 25 121 39 129 39 Rager RAG 97 10 253 77 122 40 127 44 Curtiss CUR 102 38 239 53 123 41 132 26 Bobcat BOB 92 6 228 39 125 42 87 61 Real Time RPI RTR 108 73 240 56 125 43 172 37 Craig D CRD 101 31 236 47 126 44 122 30 Maas MAA 99 24 222 32 126 45 101 48 Schmidt SCH 107 65 221 31 127 46 142 48 Whitlock WLK 105 58 227 37 127 47 142 48 Palm PSR 99 24 249 70 127 48 142 13 McCormick MCK 79 3 201 7 129 49 59 54 Coffey COF 105 58 234 43 129 50 151 28 Bowl Champ Series BCS 97 10 227 38 130 51 99 47 Welch WEL 99 24 245 65 131 52 141 68 ARGH ARG 110 77 244 63 131 53 193 65 Colton CTN 108 73 244 62 131 54 189 27 Sorensen SOR 97 10 216 23 131 55 88 76 Mark MRK 116 85 251 73 133 56 214 73 MAU MAU 114 82 247 68 133 57 207 69 Billingsley BIL 106 62 251 74 134 58 194 79 GB Eldredge GBE 107 65 280 94 134 59 218 72 BoCaDuck BCD 107 65 258 81 135 60 206 65 Eck ECK 103 43 260 85 138 61 189 53 Suni SUN 104 50 227 36 138 62 148 64 MJS Standings MJS 102 38 261 87 139 63 188 57 Armstrong ARM 104 50 235 45 139 64 159 88 Elrod ERD 115 84 293 96 142 65 245 63 Graham GRM 103 43 252 76 142 66 185 80 CSL CSL 106 62 274 92 143 67 221 75 DeSimone DES 104 50 275 93 143 68 211 89 Tellshow TSW 118 88 290 95 145 69 252 71 Gupta GUP 104 50 260 84 145 70 204 62 Hermrats HER 103 43 243 61 148 71 175 52 AccuRatings ACU 97 10 244 64 150 72 146 58 Trexler TRX 103 43 236 48 150 73 164 34 Fleming FMG 95 7 224 34 152 74 115 70 Solecismic SOL 102 38 272 90 155 75 203 74 GRS GRS 114 82 239 51 155 76 209 60 Imes IMS 99 24 245 66 157 77 167 36 Dokter DOK 97 10 220 29 159 78 117 95 Pankratz PFZ 122 95 308 100 165 79 274 67 Kiser KIS 103 43 247 69 168 80 192 86 Marsee MAR 110 77 259 82 168 81 240 92 P-Rating P+ 108 73 333 102 180 82 257 56 Bassett BAS 101 31 235 44 195 83 158 81 Dwiggins DWI 105 58 259 83 195 84 225 94 Moore MOR 123 97 263 89 201 85 271 84 Reid REI 118 88 241 58 201 86 232 86 UCS UCS 107 65 261 88 203 87 240 81 Keeper KEE 113 80 240 57 206 88 225 90 Lawler LAW 121 93 249 71 209 89 253 91 Kislanko KLK 121 93 250 72 210 90 255 99 DKC DKC 125 99 313 101 217 91 291 93 Congrove CGV 113 80 306 98 219 92 270 98 D1ACF DCF 123 97 308 99 220 93 289 85 Dolphin Pred DP 119 90 239 52 220 94 236 76 Real Time RPI RPI 108 73 236 46 224 95 214 95 Markov MKV(E-R) 126 100 255 78 233 96 274 100 Kambour KAM 139 104 273 91 233 97 292 103 Gridmarks GM 126 100 342 103 243 98 301 95 Pigskin PIG 122 95 257 80 243 99 274 81 Yearsley YEA 116 85 229 40 263 100 225 78 Nutshell NUT 117 87 219 28 276 101 216 104 MAY MAY 126 100 344 104 310 102 306 105 SCP SCP 147 105 365 105 312 103 313 102 Born BRN 128 103 260 86 321 104 293 100 SportsDoc SD 119 90 294 97 380 105 292 |
|
|
|
